Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Arlecchino

Exit Abbott and Rossouw

Recommended Posts

I am sure we all have an opinion on this subject and both sides of the argument will have very valid reasons. The question is: have these youngsters been given a fair chance and is Domingo entitled to openly criticise their decisions to leave?

Both of these guys are gifted and hard working. Rossouw has been singled out as the bigger "traitor" by Domongo who states that he told Rossouw that he is almost as good as de Villiers and is just behind him on the pecking order. If that is so, why pick Bavuma?

With regard to the case for Abbott, the coach states that the decision was a complete surprise and that CSA were "never given a chance to make their sales pitch". Too late say I. Why say anything about making such a pitch. Each contracted player deserves to be kept informed of his career path. The treatment of Abbott over the past 3 years or so has been a disgrace and Domingo must take full responsibility.

There will always be offers from clubs like Hampshire or even from the limited overs tournament teams which will make it hard to keep poorly paid and badly treated players like these two at home.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Some people seem to forget that the player life-span is very short........and yes, who's going to pay the bills???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest Stefan

Can never respect Ab£ott and Ros£ouw again. If they are as good as they think they are they could have gotten a 20/20 league deal somewhere without giving up on international cricket...

No one except the best of the best super stars are ever assured of anything in pro sports....

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Stefan said:

.........they could have gotten a 20/20 league deal somewhere without giving up on international cricket...

Unless they wanted to play cricket........

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 hours ago, Stefan said:

Can never respect Ab£ott and Ros£ouw again. If they are as good as they think they are they could have gotten a 20/20 league deal somewhere without giving up on international cricket...

No one except the best of the best super stars are ever assured of anything in pro sports....

 

Unless you sign a four year kolpak deal with income guarantees.

I don't blame the players for the making the decision to sign - a bird in the hand ......................

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

another perspective...........

Change sets Proteas on right path - Firdose Moonda 03 Feb 2017 00:00

Dismantling the cricket 'clique': Keshav Maharaj is one of the cricketers scouted by a committee of four that does not include the national captain, Faf du Plessis, nor the coach Russell Domingo. (Petri Oeschger/Gallo/Getty)

The cliques running cricket have been dismissed, allowing the best players to shine. And this, incidentally, means an embarrassment of riches in the form of black players.

Before balking, consider the evidence. Results are on the up, Cricket South Africa (CSA) is well in the black and there has been a major mind-set shift, which has taken the national team from a unit that enjoyed success with a small core of senior players to an inclusive outfit.

The main difference lies in leadership, specifically when it comes to selection. Before June 2015, when Linda Zondi was appointed as the convener, the national captain and coach were on the five-man panel that would pick a match-day XI. Between them, they held two votes and only had to convince one other person to agree with them to get their way. More often that not, that is what happened.

Since Zondi’s appointment, that has changed. Neither the coach nor the captain has any say in selection, although their opinions are sought and debated. A four-man committee – Zondi, Hussein Manack, Errol Stewart and Lux Qoboshiyana – who each attend between 30 and 40 days of domestic cricket in a season, chooses the squad and every team that takes to the field.

Sometimes the coach and captain disagree with that choice – as was the case when Rilee Rossouw was picked ahead of Hashim Amla in the one-day international (ODI) series in Australia last October – and sometimes they are pleasantly surprised.

Faf du Plessis had never seen Knights’ pacemen Duanne Olivier bowl before he faced him in the nets before the Wanderers Test in January and was similarly unfamiliar with Dolphins’ off spinner Keshav Maharaj, who was picked ahead of Dane Piedt to tour Australia last year.

The selectors had watched Olivier rise to the top of the first-class wicket-takers’ list this season and Maharaj claim 72 scalps over the past two summers and cost his team only three runs an over. They knew what Olivier and Maharaj were capable of and picked them on that basis – Du Plessis and Russell Domingo trusted their judgment and the benefit is obvious.

That is essentially the difference between the South African team of the past and the one of the present: it has neither complete control nor does it consider itself all-knowing.

“There used to be an obvious clique and now it is difficult to see any of that. Personalities have changed. There is a much greater respect for the system, perhaps because the system works a lot better,” said an insider who did not want to be named.

In 2014, CSA undertook an overhaul of their corporate governance to include independent members on their board and have since filtered that model down to franchises and provinces. The result is a more transparent operation, which has resulted in South Africa outgrowing the old boys’ club approach and moving towards a healthier culture.

Crucially, they have accepted the necessity of transformation, and the advantages it creates by opening up a much larger talent pool, which they have done throughout their structures. CSA’s 12-member board is made up of 11 members of colour, an indication that change starts at the top.

But “transformation is not the goal. Normalisation is the goal,” the insider said. “You want to get to a point where you are not thinking about whether the organisation or the team reflects the nation. It just does. We are getting there.”

Given how well things are going, the news that Domingo, who has seen South Africa through one of their most turbulent periods since readmission and emerged with his reputation enhanced, will have to reapply for his job was met with outrage. On closer reflection, it should not cause such angst.

His contract has already been extended three times so opening an application process may be nothing more than a formality. Domingo is likely to reapply and, depending on the results over the next months, has a reasonable chance of being reappointed.

“Russell seems to be at his best at the moment. He has come into his own as a coach and you can see some real confidence and courage coming through. He is not afraid to say when he is unhappy with things,” the
insder said.

Domingo publicly voiced his displeasure with Rossouw’s decision to abandon his international career, despite receiving support from CSA, because of serious injuries and several false starts in ODIs – four ducks in his first six innings – at a fiery press conference in early January.

Then it seemed South Africa’s structures would be destabilised by a recent spate of high-profile departures to the United Kingdom. Three more players – David Wiese, Hardus Viljoen and Dane Vilas – have since joined the exodus but South Africa remains on stable ground.

There are so many players coming through and, offered the right opportunities, South Africa will stay strong.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Absolute crap. The truth of the matter is that test cricket at the moment is the weakest that I can ever remember. This is not a great SA team merely a bit better than what the rest can muster.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We're both Fur Doos fans..............I knew you'd love it!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To go a step further in Smith's team we had probably 6 world class players in Smith, Amla, AB, Kallis, Boucher and Steyn. They were assisted by some very competent players in Prince, Philander and Morne. 

Only two of those nine are left at the current moment and Amla is showing increasing problems outside off. Philander is beginning to lose pace but remains skillful.

Out the the youngsters coming in QDK has replaced  Bouch and Rabada has the potential to replace Steyn. Smith, AB and Kallis have not been replaced.

In the current team we have two journeymen, old fashioned openers in Elgar and Cook. Cook is nearing the end of his career and see see no replacements coming through. Hopefully we can get a couple more years out of Hash. Duminy is not a test player let alone a number 4. Faf can do the Prince job but let's not forget that 12 months ago he was dropped from the test team. Bavuma's form has slumped alarmingly and I fear for him against NZ and England in seaming conditions. I also worry that the idiot selectors are gong to move him to open.

I have commented on Philander and Rabada. Abbott looked like the successor to Morne but that has gone pear shaped. We haven't had a spinner since Paul Adams so it doesn't matter who is picked.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Transformation" - can also mean from being top of the pile to going down the dust-pipe....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 1 Anonymous, 12 Guests (See full list)

    There are no registered users currently online

  • Forum Statistics

    11,623
    Total Topics
    394,418
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    20
    Total Members
    2,160
    Most Online
    TheDuke
    Newest Member
    TheDuke
    Joined
×
×
  • Create New...